Starters
Fajita Salad ~ 13.99
Served in a crispy flour tortilla bowl filled with shredded cabbage, choice of grilled fajita chicken or Certified Angus Beef ® flank steak with Mozzarella and Jack cheeses, topped with caramelized onions, sweet peppers, pico de gallo, house salsa, tequila-lime sauce and salsa verde served on the side.
Lime Chicken Tortilla Soup ~ 7.99
Crab Empanada ~ 11.99
With lime-tequila cream sauce.
Santa Fe Caesar ~ 8.99
Crisp romaine with our house dressing and Parmesan topped with our chile-dusted tortilla threads.
Add Chicken 3.99 / Add Shrimp 5.99
Conch Fritters ~ 9.99
A Caribbean Favorite! Loaded with conch, peppers, scallions, carrots and local hot sauce – St. John’s Best – spicy but GOOD! Served with our tequila lime dipping sauce.
Margarita Phil’s Wings ~ 7.99
Served with salsa fresca.
Cheddar-stuffed Jalapeños ~ 7.99
Served with our tequila lime dipping sauce.
Tri-colored Chips ~ 7.99
Made fresh every day with salsa verde, salsa fresca and black bean dip.
Naked Nachos & Black Bean / Queso Dip! ~ 12.99
Served with a basket of chips and Black Bean and Queso Dip.
Nachos - Build ’em your way!
They come with a base of our house black beans and blended cheeses, topped with salsa and drizzled tequila lime sauce.
Fajita Chicken ~ 14.99
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak ~ 16.99
Conch ~ 16.99
Shrimp ~ 16.99
Crab ~ 16.99
Grouper ~ 16.99
Veggie ~ 16.99
Ground Beef ~ 14.99
Entrees
All dinners served with our famous homemade beans and cilantro lime rice.
Enchiladas
The Local Favorite! Baked to perfection with the selection of your choice.
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Conch ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Crab ~ 18.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Quesadillas
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Conch ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Burritos
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Special! Chipotle Pulled Pork ~ 19.99
Sizzlin’ Fajitas
Served Smokin’! Accompanied with caramelized onions, peppers, cheeses, salsa and guacamole with a choice of filling.
Flank Steak 21.99
Shrimp 21.99
Conch 21.99
Fajita Chicken 19.99
Veggie 18.99
Combo (Choose Two) 23.99
Fajitas Grande
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak, Chicken & Shrimp.
1 for 24.99 / 2 for 39.99
Chalupa Con Queso
A crispy tortilla bowl layered with our black beans, Poncho’s enchilada sauce, and your choice of filling, inverted and topped with shredded cabbage, diced plum tomatoes, cheese and guacamole.
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak 16.99
Chicken 15.99
Shrimp 16.99
Grouper 16.99
Veggie 15.99
Ground Beef 15.99
Pan-roasted Grouper Fillet ~ 20.99
Topped with a plum tomato cilantro pesto.
Margarita Phil’s Burger ~ 14.99
Hand ground and blended Certified Angus Beef ® patty brushed with garlic-herb butter, grilled and topped with Chef’s cheese blend, caramelized onions and our special Don Julio 1942 secret sauce on a grilled bun. Served in a basket with our tricolor chips.
Margarita’s Hand-made Chalupas
Our chalupa dough is seasoned – rolled out, lightly pan-seared and dressed with guacamole.
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak 19.99
Shrimp or Conch 19.99
Fajita Chicken 17.99 Veggie 17.99
Veggie 17.99
Poncho Villa’s Crab & Shrimp Enchiladas ~ 20.99
A tasty blend of juicy crab and plump shrimp wrapped in twin soft corn tortillas covered with Poncho’s enchilada sauce and melted cheese.
Tacos
(3) grilled corn tortillas with choice of meat, Mozzarella and Jack cheese blend, cabbage and pico de gallo.
Fajita Chicken or Certified Angus Beef ® ground beef ~ 14.99 / Certified Angus Beef ® fajita steak ~ 17.99
Special Tacos
Chipotle Shrimp Soft Tacos ~ 22.99
Fresh AHI Tuna Soft Tacos ~ 28.99
Cheeseburger Tacos in Paradise ~ 15.99
Puffy flour tortillas filled with ground beef, Cheddar cheese, crisp lettuce, pico de gallo.
Grilled Grouper Tacos ~ 18.99
Grouper fillet pieces grilled with lime garlic butter in a choice of flour or corn tortillas with house cheese blend, cabbage and pico de gallo.
Sides / Extras:
Sour Cream ~ 1.99
Beans ~ 3.99
Cheese ~ 2.99
Rice ~ 3.99
Guacamole ~ 7.99
Fajita Salad ~ 13.99
Served in a crispy flour tortilla bowl filled with shredded cabbage, choice of grilled fajita chicken or Certified Angus Beef ® flank steak with Mozzarella and Jack cheeses, topped with caramelized onions, sweet peppers, pico de gallo, house salsa, tequila-lime sauce and salsa verde served on the side.
Lime Chicken Tortilla Soup ~ 7.99
Crab Empanada ~ 11.99
With lime-tequila cream sauce.
Santa Fe Caesar ~ 8.99
Crisp romaine with our house dressing and Parmesan topped with our chile-dusted tortilla threads.
Add Chicken 3.99 / Add Shrimp 5.99
Conch Fritters ~ 9.99
A Caribbean Favorite! Loaded with conch, peppers, scallions, carrots and local hot sauce – St. John’s Best – spicy but GOOD! Served with our tequila lime dipping sauce.
Margarita Phil’s Wings ~ 7.99
Served with salsa fresca.
Cheddar-stuffed Jalapeños ~ 7.99
Served with our tequila lime dipping sauce.
Tri-colored Chips ~ 7.99
Made fresh every day with salsa verde, salsa fresca and black bean dip.
Naked Nachos & Black Bean / Queso Dip! ~ 12.99
Served with a basket of chips and Black Bean and Queso Dip.
Nachos - Build ’em your way!
They come with a base of our house black beans and blended cheeses, topped with salsa and drizzled tequila lime sauce.
Fajita Chicken ~ 14.99
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak ~ 16.99
Conch ~ 16.99
Shrimp ~ 16.99
Crab ~ 16.99
Grouper ~ 16.99
Veggie ~ 16.99
Ground Beef ~ 14.99
Entrees
All dinners served with our famous homemade beans and cilantro lime rice.
Enchiladas
The Local Favorite! Baked to perfection with the selection of your choice.
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Conch ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Crab ~ 18.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Quesadillas
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Conch ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Burritos
Flank Steak ~ 17.99
Shrimp ~ 17.99
Grouper ~ 17.99
Chicken ~ 15.99
Veggie ~ 15.99
Ground Beef ~ 15.99
Special! Chipotle Pulled Pork ~ 19.99
Sizzlin’ Fajitas
Served Smokin’! Accompanied with caramelized onions, peppers, cheeses, salsa and guacamole with a choice of filling.
Flank Steak 21.99
Shrimp 21.99
Conch 21.99
Fajita Chicken 19.99
Veggie 18.99
Combo (Choose Two) 23.99
Fajitas Grande
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak, Chicken & Shrimp.
1 for 24.99 / 2 for 39.99
Chalupa Con Queso
A crispy tortilla bowl layered with our black beans, Poncho’s enchilada sauce, and your choice of filling, inverted and topped with shredded cabbage, diced plum tomatoes, cheese and guacamole.
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak 16.99
Chicken 15.99
Shrimp 16.99
Grouper 16.99
Veggie 15.99
Ground Beef 15.99
Pan-roasted Grouper Fillet ~ 20.99
Topped with a plum tomato cilantro pesto.
Margarita Phil’s Burger ~ 14.99
Hand ground and blended Certified Angus Beef ® patty brushed with garlic-herb butter, grilled and topped with Chef’s cheese blend, caramelized onions and our special Don Julio 1942 secret sauce on a grilled bun. Served in a basket with our tricolor chips.
Margarita’s Hand-made Chalupas
Our chalupa dough is seasoned – rolled out, lightly pan-seared and dressed with guacamole.
Certified Angus Beef ® Flank Steak 19.99
Shrimp or Conch 19.99
Fajita Chicken 17.99 Veggie 17.99
Veggie 17.99
Poncho Villa’s Crab & Shrimp Enchiladas ~ 20.99
A tasty blend of juicy crab and plump shrimp wrapped in twin soft corn tortillas covered with Poncho’s enchilada sauce and melted cheese.
Tacos
(3) grilled corn tortillas with choice of meat, Mozzarella and Jack cheese blend, cabbage and pico de gallo.
Fajita Chicken or Certified Angus Beef ® ground beef ~ 14.99 / Certified Angus Beef ® fajita steak ~ 17.99
Special Tacos
Chipotle Shrimp Soft Tacos ~ 22.99
Fresh AHI Tuna Soft Tacos ~ 28.99
Cheeseburger Tacos in Paradise ~ 15.99
Puffy flour tortillas filled with ground beef, Cheddar cheese, crisp lettuce, pico de gallo.
Grilled Grouper Tacos ~ 18.99
Grouper fillet pieces grilled with lime garlic butter in a choice of flour or corn tortillas with house cheese blend, cabbage and pico de gallo.
Sides / Extras:
Sour Cream ~ 1.99
Beans ~ 3.99
Cheese ~ 2.99
Rice ~ 3.99
Guacamole ~ 7.99
